The
U.S.-Pakistani relationship has never been a very good one. It only got worse
after 9/11 when the American people became racist and began to get aggressively
disrespectful to any Middle Eastern looking men and women. This was displayed
in The Reluctant Fundamentalist in
numerous ways and most interestingly through the eyes of a Pakistani. Because
Hamid depicts the balance between the harsh racists and the more open-minded
American’s such as Erica so well, it creates a primarily accurate portrayal of
the fragile U.S.-Pakistani relationship as it was then and now.
Hamid
portrays two different types of American psyches following the 9/11 attacks. He
illustrates the negative racism that occurred to many. This was shown when a
stranger approached Changez, the main character, in a parking lot and “made a
series of unintelligible noises—“akhala-malakhala,” perhaps, or “khalapal-khalapala”—and
pressed his face alarmingly close to mine.” (117) The stranger’s friend then
pulled him away telling him it wasn’t worth it, but as he was leaving the
stranger yelled “fucking Arab.” This obviously angered Changez because he was
Pakistani, not Arab and it was clear the man was making fun of his native
language. This was very common at the time because the attack struck fear into
so many civilians, which resulted in many of them channeling it into racism.
Hamid also shows us both ends of the spectrum. He has Erica, who Changez
crushes on, which is a very accepting young woman that is actually supportive
of his homeland. Erica often tells him how she so much enjoys hearing stories
of Pakistan. In fact Changez wears his long white cotton traditional Pakistani
styled shirt to a dinner at her house because he knows how it would please her.
Hamid made Erica as an accurate portrayal of America’s society that was
accepting and understood that not every Middle Eastern man or woman was a
terrorist so there wasn’t anything to be afraid of.
Although
Hamid was successful with most of the depiction of the U.S.-Pakistan
relationship, he still had some flaws. The main inaccuracy that I saw was
Changez smiling at the attacks of 9/11. I know that these attacks did make
those who weren’t so fond of America happy, but I don’t believe it would make
those who became a product of America happy. Changez went to school in the
U.S., worked in the U.S., and lived in the U.S. so I do not believe it would
make someone smile the way he did at the falling of the towers which is in fact
the area where he lives. Because this character is a symbol for a Middle
Eastern native living in America during this rise of racism, it would also be
wrong for this symbol to live up to these racist people’s expectations.
Overall
Hamid’s portrayal of the U.S.-Pakistan relationship was very accurate, so much
so that it is still relevant to today’s current relationship. Although the
number of racist based crimes and racism have gone down dramatically, there are
still people out there who are very racist even to this day. That is why most
Middle Eastern men and women chose to look very American. Similar to how
Changez was asked by his boss to shave his beard because it was making people uncomfortable.
This beard that is looked at as traditional in his native country was now
looked at as an image of terror in his current country. Sadly this is often
still the case today. Since the attacks happened so long ago people aren’t as
scared and worried. We have evolved to become more civil and understanding like
the novel illustrated with Erica, the symbol for America’s society.
I think you did a pretty good job here! You thesis was qualified and arguable. I really like the qoutes you used as back up for you statements. The part I agree with the most and enjoy the most is your last paragraph. The connection you made between Changez being told to shave his beard and why that Middle Eastern people choose to look more American was very good. Overall good work!
ReplyDeleteI found your analysis of the anti-muslim bigotry that Changez faces to be very key when describing the US/Pakistani relationship. You articulated yourself very well, but I think you should focus more on Underwood Sampson and it's relationship with the economy and how this mirrors America's relationship with Pakistan and other countries.
ReplyDelete